EC pushes back against reform commission proposals over weakened independence

The Election Commission (EC) has written to the National Consensus Commission, expressing its disagreement with some of the recommendations made by the Electoral Reform Commission.

The EC believes implementing these proposals would undermine its independence.

A letter was sent to National Consensus Commission Vice-Chairman Ali Riaz on Monday, said Akhtar Ahmed, the senior secretary of the EC Secretariat.

He said, "The letter addresses differing opinions on seven to eight of the Election System Reform Commission's recommendations."

The reform commission has suggested establishing an independent commission to delimit the boundaries of parliamentary constituencies.

The EC, however, has said such a commission is unnecessary.

"If the proposed formula for seat boundary re-determination is implemented, the number of seats in urban areas will increase," Akhtar added.

According to the EC, the boundaries should be redefined considering voter numbers and regional integrity.

The EC secretary said a recommendation has been made to “certify” the election results within 48 hours of voting to confirm the election was “fair”.

He added, "The Election Commission believes this is unnecessary, as the gazette notification already serves as certification.

The Election Commission also disagrees with the reform commission's recommendations regarding the accountability and punishment of election commissioners.

The EC secretary further explained that returning officers announce results only after being satisfied with them.

The reform commission has recommended investigating and punishing election commissioners if they are found guilty after an investigation following the election.

Regarding this, Akhtar said: "There is already a system in place, the Supreme Judicial Council. Would it be reasonable for election commissioners to face court proceedings five or ten years after the election ends?

“One candidate will win, while others, dissatisfied, can raise any allegations."

In addition, the commission has suggested that the National Identity Card (NID) service should remain under the control of the EC.